I didn’t really find anything on how to do this for accounts created before the attachment of e-mail addresses was made more mandatory. The Lost Account sticky also doesn’t seem to account for these beyond the bolded line that says unverified accounts can’t be recovered.
I’m not sure if there’s still a friendlier way to do it, but…
Copy and paste that into your address bar and change USERNAMEHERE, PASSWORDHERE and EMAILHERE to the appropriate values.
Let me know how that works.
Are you Sluggerdalejr? @ Kero
It appears you can also use http://www.xgenstudios.com/game.php?keyword=stickarenaclassic
After pressing Log In, there’s a link that says “Verify Email - Get Instant 500 Cred”
Click that link, and it will ask for your credentials and the desired email.